Equitable division of assets in a Rhode Island divorce is a 3 step process

The law which pertains to equitable distribution of marital assets and debts in Rhode Island is SECTION 15-5-16.1  The RI Supreme Court has stated many times that a marriage is an economic partnership. Rhode Island has equitable distribution of marital assets. Equitable does not necessarily mean equal!  Nonetheless, in the vast majority of Rhode Island divorces, marital assets are divided equally either via settlement or decision after a divorce trial. Non-economic contributions to the marriage are also very important under Rhode Island law.

Judges have wide discretion dividing marital assets

RI divorce

Rhode Island divorce lawyer

Every justice of the Rhode Island Family Court has a different world view, different history and different perspective. This means that some judges place more weight on certain factors than other judges. Judges and General Magistrates have wide discretion in equitable dividing marital assets in RI. The Rhode Island Supreme Court can only overturn a judge’s use of discretion if the Justice abused his or her discretion

An experience Rhode Island divorce attorney will likely have vast experience with the judge who will be deciding a divorce. A husband and wife would be well advised to retain an experienced RI divorce lawyer

For an in depth explanation of what  exactly constitutes marital assets in Rhode Island, please visit: What Constitutes Marital Property in Rhode Island (RI) subject to the equitable distribution statute in a divorce?

Court must equitable divide marital assets

In Stanzler v Stanzler, The Rhode Island Supreme Court stated, “It is well established that the intent of property division is to provide a fair and just assignment of the marital assets, D’Agostino v. D’Agostino, 463 A.2d 200, 203 (R.I. 1983), on the basis of the joint contribution of the spouses to the marital enterprise. Wordell v. Wordell, 470 A.2d 665, 667 (R.I. 1984). Property division, however, does not require an equal division of the property, Casey v. Casey, 494 A.2d 80, 82-83 (R.I. 1985), and is subject to the concept that nonmonetary, as well as monetary, contributions may enhance the marital partnership. Wordell, 470 A.2d at 667.” Milton STANZLER v. Phyllis STANZLER. 560 A.2d 342 (1989) No. 88-459-A. Supreme Court of Rhode Island June 21, 1989. 343*343 Milton Stanzler, Cerilli, McGuirl, Hustwit & Bicki, William J. McGair, Providence, for plaintiff. Dewitt T. Kersh, Jr., Tillinghast, Collins & Graham, Providence, for defendant.

Equitable division of assets, a three step process

divorce in Rhode Island, attorneys

divorce law in RI

The Court must first determine what is a marital asset and which assets are not marital assets. After making a determination of what constitutes a marital asset under Rhode Island law, the Rhode Island Family Court justice must consider the factors enumerated in RI law SECTION 15-5-16.1 . The Providence Family Court Justice or General Magistrate must, as the third step, divide the marital assets.

It is important to realize, that a vast majority or Rhode Island divorce causes of action settle prior to a trial starting. Of the cases in which a divorce trial begins with testimony, a vast majority of those cases settle before a Judge of the Rhode Island Family Court issues a decision.

Identifying marital assets in RI

“Identifying which assets are included in the overall marital pot is a crucial first step in the distribution process.   See Vanni, 535 A.2d at 1270.  “We have previously stated that a trial justice in undertaking to distribute marital assets must initially separate nonmarital assets from the marital assets in accordance with § 15-5-16.1.” DiOrio v. DiOrio, 751 A.2d 747, 751 (R.I.2000) (quoting Gervais, 688 A.2d at 1305).   Under § 15-5-16.1(a), the Family Court is granted broad discretionary authority to “assign to either the husband or wife a portion of the estate of the other.”  Supreme Court of Rhode Island. Rosemarie RUFFEL v. Lance RUFFEL. No. 2004-6-Appeal. Decided: June 28, 2006 Present:  WILLIAMS, C.J., GOLDBERG, FLAHERTY, SUTTELL, and ROBINSON, JJ. Lauren E. Jones, Esq., Providence, for Plaintiff. Robert S. Parker, Esq., Providence, for Defendant.

§ 15-5-16.1 Assignment of property.

Rhode Island law 15-5-16.1 sets forth 12 factors that a Rhode Island Family Court Justice “shall consider” in equitable assigning the assets of the marital partnership. The twelfth factor is possibly the most interesting because it includes a catchall. Does this catchall eviscerate the other 11 factors meaning the judge can just do whatever the judge believes is fair?

“(1) The length of the marriage; (2) The conduct of the parties during the marriage; (3) The contribution of each of the parties during the marriage in the acquisition, preservation, or appreciation in value of their respective estates; (4) The contribution and services of either party as a homemaker; (5) The health and age of the parties; (6) The amount and sources of income of each of the parties; (7) The occupation and employability of each of the parties; (8) The opportunity of each party for future acquisition of capital assets and income; (9) The contribution by one party to the education, training, licensure, business, or increased earning power of the other; (10) The need of the custodial parent to occupy or own the marital residence and to use or own its household effects taking into account the best interests of the children of the marriage; (11) Either party’s wasteful dissipation of assets or any transfer or encumbrance of assets made in contemplation of divorce without fair consideration; and (12) Any factor which the court shall expressly find to be just and proper.” SECTION 15-5-16.1

A Providence Family Court Justice’s decision can only be overturned by RI Supreme Court based on an “abuse of discretion”

“In dividing property, a trial justice must decide which assets are marital property, consider the contribution of each party, and then distribute the property. Lancellotti v. Lancellotti, 481 A.2d 7, 10 (R.I. 1984). Finally we note that a trial justice’s assignment of property will not be overturned unless it constitutes an abuse of discretion. Centazzo v. Centazzo, 509 A.2d 995, 997 (R.I. 1986)Stanzler v Stanzler

 

 

 

 

 

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email

Morning calendar call in RI Family Court is Gobbledygook- Part 1-3

Rhode Island Family Court lawyers and RI associates Justices, Magistrates  and members of the bar are so  well versed in the bizarre and sometimes anachronistic calendar call it has become nearly normal. The key word here is "nearly".  Lets call it … [Continue reading]

Rhode Island Divorce laws

  Rhode Island divorce attorney, David Slepkow answers several basic yet important questions concerning Rhode Island divorce law and procedure. These  Rhode island divorce law questions will help Divorce litigants and those thinking about … [Continue reading]

Letter for children to give to parents to stop custody war

Here is a letter for children to give to their parents who are involved in a highly contested and bitter custody, visitation or divorce war. This letter is for kids who want their parents to stop fighting and feuding regarding custody and … [Continue reading]

Common reasons why people request to modify child support

Many people are unaware that after a child support amount is established by the Providence Family Court, it can be changed. The RI Family Court Court will require that the reason for the change is valid and that there has been a substantial change in … [Continue reading]

Less Common Reasons for Divorce in Rhode Island

Providence Family Court attorneys

This divorce post was authored by Rhode Island Divorce lawyer, David Slepkow. David explains some less common reasons for divorce. Divorce attorney in RI In most cases, the pathway that leads to divorce or separation is very understandable to every … [Continue reading]

Surviving Divorce: The do’s and don’ts post divorce

Surviving a divorce in Rhode Island can be a vulnerable and painful time that seems to never end. In addition to the emotional fallout, many ex-spouses face numerous post-divorce issues involving child support, spousal maintenance, custody issues, … [Continue reading]

When can a child decide which parent to live with?

Is there a particular age when a child in Rhode Island can decide which parent they want to reside with, in a RI child custody, post divorce or Divorce cause of action? Can a child in Rhode Island decide where they want to live? There is no set age … [Continue reading]

Navigating a High Conflict Divorce

Every divorce is stressful and and often brings out the worst out in most of us. However, a high conflict divorce is far more nerve-racking when couples engage in hostile or aggressive confrontation instead of using legal negotiation tools to resolve … [Continue reading]

Haphazard life insurance trusts common in divorce | How to do properly

After months of arguing, motions and tedious discovery in a RI divorce, someone remembers the life insurance policies, at the last minute. Everyone is worn down. Everyone wants to get the ghastly divorce over, as soon as possible. Life insurance … [Continue reading]

To Prenup or Not to Prenup in RI? That is the question…

While the prospect of marriage in Rhode Island is often a fulfillment of a lifetime dream for most couples, it is unfortunate to note that the majority of the marriages end up in a divorce. This is where a prenuptial agreement, otherwise known as an … [Continue reading]

Important Considerations in Drafting a RI Prenuptial Agreement

A prenuptial agreement in Rhode Island should be drafted by a RI divorce attorney or a Rhode Island prenuptial agreement lawyer. In modern times, prenuptial agreements are typically referred to as "premarital agreements." At the end of the day, … [Continue reading]

Step-By-Step Advice For Those Thinking About Divorce in RI

Divorce is a word that strikes fear into the heart of pretty much the vast majority of married men or woman in the world. After all, a divorce signifies a major change in your personal life, and chances are you went into your marriage thinking it … [Continue reading]

10 critical mistakes some people make during their divorce

Going through the process of divorce in Rhode Island can be an emotionally trying experience. After all, no one goes into marriage with the thought of divorce looming in their minds. While it can often times be difficult to see the forest for the … [Continue reading]

Why Most States & RI Have Made No-Fault Divorce the Standard

For generations, proving fault, or  the seedy or unsavory action of one spouse was the only option or grounds to obtain a divorce. However, no-fault divorce has become very popular in recent years as a way to eliminate a legal and permanent … [Continue reading]

Top causes of divorce in Rhode Island

Marriage, even between couples in love, is never easy. Even though we enter into marriage with the best intentions and the hope of a permanent future with another, most of us will divorce in time. If you are in need of a divorce in Rhode Island, call … [Continue reading]

RI Child Support | Private School & College Education Liability

Rhode Island child support lawyer, David Slepkow answers several frequently asked questions pertaining to liability for college and private school pursuant to RI child support law. Can I get the other parent to be ordered to contribute to my child's … [Continue reading]

Random important advice from RI divorce and custody attorney

A Rhode Island divorce lawyer provides free advice concerning RI family law.  Do not exaggerate Do not exaggerate or embellish your case  at a hearing in front of a Rhode Island Family Court Justice or Magistrate. Credibility and Perception is … [Continue reading]

Should sole custody be abolished in Rhode Island?

Parties who are involved in a child custody case, divorce or miscellaneous custodial petition in Providence and Kent County Family Courts typically agree to share joint custody over their minor children. Some of these agreements are driven by a … [Continue reading]

Rhode Island child support statistics and information

In Rhode Island, non-custodial parents have a legal requirement to pay their child support on a regular basis regardless if they live in the state or not. When the payment is not made, the non-custodial parent is subject to strict enforcement … [Continue reading]

Responsible Ways to Tell Your Children about the Divorce in RI

When children hear that their parents are divorcing, they often have a sense of abandonment, fearing they will be on their own without help. Even though most spouses are anxious and perturbed about the thought of informing the children, it is … [Continue reading]

Child Custody in RI: How a Divorce Impacts Children

In many ways, children of divorced parents in Rhode Island live a life different from those who stay at home in a stable family environment. Many married couples in RI will divorce believing that their children were unhappy because their parents were … [Continue reading]

Divorce in RI- Part 5/5 “The Divorce Trial on the Merits”

This is the last segment of Rhode Island divorce attorney, David Slepkow's comprehensive five part series concerning divorce in RI.  This post focuses on divorce trials in Providence Family Court. Also see: Part 1 of 5 , Part 2 of 5, Part 3- of … [Continue reading]

Indicators: time to settle bitterly contested divorce war

Rhode Island divorce attorney, David Slepkow, presents the top indicators that it is time to end your dreadful RI divorce war. If any of these indicators are present in your Providence Family Court Divorce, it is time to set up a settlement … [Continue reading]

The RI Discovery Process- Rhode Island Divorce A-Z (Part 4-5)

This is part 4 of a 5 part series by Rhode Island divorce lawyer, David Slepkow concerning Divorce in RI. This post focuses on the discovery process in Providence Family Court. Part 1 of 5   Part 2 of 5    Part 3- of 5 After commencing a … [Continue reading]

10 Rhode Island Child Custody and Divorce Tips

A Rhode Island child custody attorney sets forth 10 important divorce and custody tips to help clients navigate through the complex process of Providence Family Court. Important Family Court tips: Never make negative or disparaging remarks … [Continue reading]

More Providence Family Court Tips & Some Divorce Stats

A Rhode Island Family Court attorney who regularly litigates divorce and custody cases in Providence Family Court, sets forth numerous divorce tips to help litigants in Family Court. Please read these tips very carefully! 1. Perception is reality in … [Continue reading]

RI Family Court Enters Digital Age with E files & E Filing!

The Rhode Island Family Court, in all counties, across the State of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, are taking the plunge into the digital age. The Providence Family Court will begin the process of going all digital beginning tomorrow … [Continue reading]

Basic Rhode Island Divorce FAQS by a RI divorce attorney

Rhode Island divorce lawyer, David Slepkow answers numerous questions about divorce law in Rhode Island. David Slepkow is an experienced Providence Family Court attorney  / RI divorce lawyer who has represented clients in hundreds of divorces in … [Continue reading]

Say it Aint So ABC News! ABC’s horrible RI Divorce Article

ABC News recently released an article entitled, "Top 7 Worst States for Divorce". This article is terrible journalism. It is wrong in nearly all respects concerning Rhode Island divorce law. This is shameful conduct on the part of ABC news.  Read the … [Continue reading]